Your marketing agency send you a report every month and the figures look pretty impressive. Is your business actually getting any benefit out of it though?
Site traffic is up. Social media engagement is up. The latest campaign alone has delivered thousands of impressions.
Your agency seems pleased.
But your sales team aren’t seeing any more qualified enquiries, your pipeline isn’t growing and you’re starting to wonder what on earth you’re actually paying for.
It’s a very familiar scenario for a lot of SMEs.
Marketing agencies can bring a wealth of expertise, creativity and specialist resources. A good agency can make a real difference to business growth.
But using an agency doesn’t in any way guarantee that your marketing will be effective.
And getting a monthly report doesn’t in any way imply that anyone is being held to account.
If you’re investing in external marketing support then you need to know what success looks like, how you’re going to measure performance and whether the work is actually going to contribute to your commercial objectives.
Here’s how to do that.
How Do You Hold a Marketing Agency Accountable?
The best way to hold a marketing agency to account is to set clear business objectives, agree on measurable KPIs, define responsibilities and then review performance on a regular basis.
For the vast majority of SMEs that means looking beyond the marketing activity and actually understanding how the agency work contributes to qualified leads, sales opportunities, customer acquisition and business growth.
Accountability doesn’t mean that an agency is going to be responsible for sales or for any of the things that are outside their control.
It means agreeing on what the agency is responsible for delivering, agreeing on the right outcomes to measure and then making the right decisions about performance.
1. Start with Business Objectives, Not Marketing Activities
One of the biggest errors that businesses make when engaging an agency is to start with the activity rather than the objective.
“We need more social media.”
“We should be doing Google Ads.”
“Our competitors are investing in SEO.”
These might all be perfectly reasonable suggestions.
So what are you actually after?
Are you after more qualified sales enquiries? A new market? Higher customer retention? More demand for a new product?
Before you go any further and agree to do any marketing activity at all you need to have a commercial objective in mind.
For instance rather than asking an agency to get more traffic on the site you might be asking them to help attract more of the right kind of visitor who are going to convert.
That in turn creates a very different conversation around targeting, messaging, content and performance.
The question isn’t just what your agency are doing, it’s why they’re doing it and what the business is expecting to achieve.
2. Agree on Marketing KPIs That Actually Matter
Key performance indicators (KPIs) are a way of working out whether your marketing is actually progressing towards its objectives, but not all KPIs are equally useful.
Lots of agency reports are all about the metrics that are easy to measure (impressions, clicks, website sessions, follower count, engagement etc).
These figures have their place.
They can be used to spot trends, assess the delivery of the campaign and flag up potential problems.
But they don’t necessarily indicate commercial success.
For most SMEs, more meaningful measures might include:
- Qualified enquiries generated
- Cost per qualified lead
- Sales opportunities influenced by marketing
- Conversion rates
- Customer acquisition costs
- Revenue and gross profit attributable to marketing
- Return on marketing investment.
The right KPIs will of course be down to your business model, your objectives and your sales cycle.
For a technical B2B company selling specialist equipment, five genuinely qualified enquiries are likely to be worth a heck of a lot more than 500 irrelevant leads.
Ensure your agency fully understand the difference between creating activity and creating commercial value.
3. Make Sure Your Agency Understands Your Business
An agency can be absolutely brilliant at digital marketing and still not get results if they don’t understand your customers.
This is absolutely critical in the B2B manufacturing, engineering, technology and other specialist fields.
Your customers may have quite complex requirements, very lengthy purchase processes and a number of stakeholders involved in the decision making.
The person who’s researching the solution may well be a different person to the one who’s going to be approving the budget.
And the initial enquiry may well be months away from becoming a sale.
Your agency should know who your ideal customer is, what problems they need solving, how they assess suppliers and why they might go with you rather than a competitor.
If your agency don’t get these fundamentals then it’s very difficult to run any kind of effective campaign.
Ask your agency to define your target audience and to explain how their proposed activities will impact their decision to buy.
If the explanation is weak then you may have actually identified a more fundamental problem than campaign performance.
4. Establish Clear Responsibilities
Marketing agencies are frequently to blame for problems that they don’t entirely have control over.
An agency may well produce qualified leads but if your sales team take two weeks to get back then those opportunities are effectively dead.
Similarly an agency may bring the right kind of visitors to your site, but if your proposition is unclear or your enquiry process is difficult then you’ll never get any conversions.
That’s why accountability has to work both ways.
Who is responsible for strategy, campaign delivery, content approval, website performance, lead management, reporting and sales follow-up?
If the agency are the ones responsible for generating the qualified leads then agree what constitutes a qualified lead and how that information will be captured.
If your business is the one that’s converting the leads then you need to be able to measure what happens after the enquiry.
You can’t hold an agency to account for outcomes unless you’ve got clear responsibilities.
5. Ask Better Questions During Monthly Reviews
A monthly agency meeting shouldn’t just be someone going through a dashboard to you.
It should be an opportunity to assess performance, challenge the assumptions and agree what happens next.
Rather than asking how many impressions a campaign generated, try asking:
- What’s improved since last month and why?
- What activities are generating the most commercially valuable enquiries?
- What’s not working as expected?
- What have we learned about our customers?
- What should we stop doing?
- Where should we be investing more and what’s the evidence for that?
- What are the priorities for the next 30 days?
These questions take the conversation away from simply reporting on what’s happening and towards actually improving performance.
A good agency would embrace them.
It must be able to explain its decisions, admit when it’s underperforming and then recommend the appropriate changes based on evidence.
If every monthly meeting ends with everything apparently going absolutely splendidly, despite there being very little commercial progress, it’s entirely legitimate to wonder whether you actually have the full picture.
6. Make Sure You Own Your Marketing Data and Accounts
Your business should have appropriate ownership and control over its marketing assets.
That includes your website, domain, analytics properties, advertising accounts, CRM data and all your other business critical systems.
Agencies may well need access to the platforms in order to manage them, but you shouldn’t end up being overly reliant on the supplier for access to your own information.
Before you go ahead and appoint an agency you need to be absolutely clear on account ownership, access rights, what data is going to be handled and what happens if the relationship ultimately comes to an end.
Also ensure you can independently review the performance information.
You don’t necessarily need to have a deep understanding of every technical aspect of Google Analytics or advertising attribution.
You should be able to get at the underlying data and be confident that the reporting is accurate.
Transparency is not an optional add on. It’s a fundamental requirement of a healthy agency relationship.
7. Measure Marketing ROI, Not Just Agency Activity
Ultimately the business owner wants to know is their marketing spend worth it.
That’s about understanding what you’re spending and the commercial value that the investment generates.
Marketing return on investment can provide that perspective.
A useful gross-profit-based calculation is:
Marketing ROI (%) = [(Gross Profit Attributable to Marketing − Marketing Costs) ÷ Marketing Costs] × 100
For instance, imagine your business is spending £3,000 on a campaign.
The campaign generates £15k in attributable revenue, with £6k in direct costs of the products/services sold.
That leaves £9,000 gross profit before marketing expenditure.
Your marketing ROI would be: [(£9,000 − £3,000) ÷ £3,000] × 100 = 200%
This means the campaign generated £2 of additional contribution after marketing costs for every £1 that was invested.
Of course attribution isn’t always that simple.
Customers will have interacted with a number of marketing channels prior to the purchase in the case of B2B markets with long sales cycles.
Some of the activities also work to build future demand rather than producing any immediate sales.
The key thing is to use a consistent commercially meaningful measure rather than just go with the platform stats.
For more detail, have a read of my guide to measuring marketing ROI if you’re running a small business.
8. Know When to Challenge Your Agency
Not every bad result is evidence of poor agency performance.
Marketing takes time (especially if you’re trying to build organic search visibility, brand awareness or get into a new market).
External factors can also have an effect on performance.
But there are warning signs worth looking into.
Perhaps your agency is regularly missing the agreed objectives without giving a very good explanation.
Perhaps it’s all about the eye-catching figures and completely ignores the qualified leads or commercial outcomes.
You’ll note that the recommendations don’t tend to change at all, even when the performance is still very much in the disappointing bracket.
Or maybe the agency are more interested in selling you further services than in actually improving the effectiveness of your current investment.
None of that necessarily means you should end the relationship.
But they should be prompting a proper debate about expectations, the evidence and what changes would be required.
A good agency relationship is about honest conversations not just positive reports.
9. Don’t Expect Your Agency to Be Your Marketing Director
This is a crucial distinction. An agency is normally engaged to provide the specific marketing services.
That might include SEO, advertising, content production, design, website development or campaign management.
Some agencies also provide strategic leadership, but this should be explicitly agreed, not assumed.
Your business still needs someone to decide what marketing should achieve, which audiences matter, how resources should be allocated and how performance supports wider commercial objectives.
For bigger organisations that responsibility may lie with a Marketing Director or CMO.
For smaller businesses it’s often down to the owner or MD.
And that’s where the problems can arise.
Running a business doesn’t in any way automatically mean that you have the time, the experience or the specialist knowledge to go and challenge every single marketing recommendation.
Without independent strategic oversight you can find yourself reliant on the suppliers to recommend the services that they themselves are selling.
That’s not necessarily a criticism of the agency.
It’s a question of structure and accountability.
10. Consider Independent Marketing Oversight
Sometimes the most effective way to improve agency performance is simply not to change the agencies. It’s to introduce experienced marketing leadership.
An independent marketing consultant or Fractional Marketing Director can help to establish the strategy, agree on sensible objectives, assess the agency’s recommendations and then monitor commercial performance.
They can also be used to make sure that the various suppliers are all working towards the same business objectives.
For instance your SEO agency will be looking at organic visibility and your paid advertising supplier will be looking at the immediate enquiries.
Both of those could be useful.
But someone needs to understand how they fit into the wider customer acquisition strategy and whether the total investment is commercially viable.
Independent oversight can help to spot duplication, improve coordination and challenge spending that isn’t delivering sufficient value.
The aim isn’t to make life difficult for your agencies. It’s to help them deliver better results for your business.
A Simple Marketing Agency Performance Scorecard
You don’t need an elaborate reporting system to get accountability.
For a large number of SMEs a simple monthly scorecard is quite sufficient to underpin more meaningful conversations.
| Area | What to review |
| Business objectives | Are activities supporting agreed commercial priorities? |
| Campaign delivery | Has the agency completed the agreed work? |
| Qualified enquiries | Are campaigns attracting suitable prospects? |
| Lead quality | Are enquiries relevant to your target customers? |
| Cost efficiency | What does each qualified lead or acquisition cost? |
| Sales contribution | Are leads progressing into opportunities and customers? |
| Marketing ROI | Is the financial return justifying the investment? |
| Recommendations | What should change based on the evidence? |
Not every metric will be available immediately, particularly where the sales cycle is long.
The key thing is to establish a consistent approach and to simply improve the quality of your reporting over time.
What Should You Do If Your Marketing Agency Isn’t Delivering?
Before making a decision, I’d recommend reviewing three things.
First, was the agency given clear commercial objectives? If expectations were vague, it’s worth correcting that before judging performance.
Second, does the evidence demonstrate underperformance? Look at agreed KPIs, lead quality, conversion rates, and the time reasonably required to achieve results.
Third, has the agency responded constructively to the problems? A capable agency should be willing to explain what’s happening, identify improvements and agree a realistic action plan.
If the relationship can be improved, then set a clear performance improvement period with agreed milestones.
If the fundamental strategy is wrong you may well need to fix that before you can expect any different results.
And if trust has broken down or the agency can’t demonstrate sufficient value then it may be time to look at alternative support.
The decision should be based on evidence not frustration.
How Makin Marketing Helps Businesses Get More from Their Marketing Agencies
I’m Sean Makin, founder of Makin Marketing, a marketing consultancy based in Fife providing support to SMEs right across Scotland and the wider UK.
Having spent over 25 years in B2B marketing (primarily in the technical, engineering and science driven sectors) I know the difficulties of marketing spend management, supplier management and demonstrating commercial value.
I work directly with business owners, founders and MDs to bring clarity, direction and accountability to their marketing.
That could involve a review of the existing agency relationship, a review of marketing performance, the development of a clearer strategy and/or the establishment of more meaningful reporting.
I also provide ongoing support in the role of a Fractional Marketing Director, helping businesses to manage their internal teams and their external suppliers without the cost of a full time senior marketing appointment.
My approach is not about knocking out agencies unnecessarily. It’s about making sure your marketing spend is being used effectively and that everyone in the marketing team understands what they’re working towards.
Because a good marketing agency can be an excellent partner.
But even the very best partners need clear direction.
Frequently Asked Questions About Marketing Agency Accountability
How do I know if my marketing agency are doing a good job?
Assess performance against the agreed objectives, relevant KPIs, quality of delivery and commercial outcomes. A good agency will provide transparent reporting, will explain its recommendations and will be able to show how its work contributes to your business objectives.
What KPIs should a marketing agency be reporting on?
The right KPIs will of course vary depending on the services you’re providing and your business objectives. Some of the more common ones are qualified leads, conversion rates, cost per acquisition, campaign performance and revenue contribution. Impressions and clicks can be useful in the analysis but shouldn’t be the only KPIs you’re tracking.
Should a marketing agency guarantee results?
Be very wary of any guarantees relating to search rankings, sales or revenue as those are all dependent on factors which are outside the agency’s control. The agency should be agreeing on achievable targets, clear deliverables, appropriate KPIs and a transparent method of improvement.
How frequently should I be reviewing the performance of my marketing agency?
Monthly operational reviews are useful for looking at activity and short term performance. The quarterly strategic reviews are better for giving you a view of the commercial outcome, particularly where you have long sales cycles.
What should I do if my agency isn’t generating leads?
Start with the strategy, the target audience, the campaign performance, the website conversion rates and the lead tracking. Work out whether the problem is with the quality of the traffic, the messaging, the conversion or the sales follow-up before you go about deciding what needs to be changed.
Can a marketing consultant run my existing agency?
Yes. An experienced marketing consultant or Fractional MD can provide strategic direction, review performance, co-ordinate suppliers and help to ensure that agency activity is in line with the wider commercial objectives.
Should I switch agencies if my marketing isn’t working?
Not necessarily. Poor results could be down to a number of things other than agency capability per se: the objectives may have been poorly defined, the strategy may have been flawed, the tracking may have been poor or the coordination may have been weak. An independent marketing review can help to identify what the real problem is before you make any judgements.
Is Your Marketing Agency Delivering the Results Your Business Needs?
If you’re investing in agency support and you’re not quite sure what the hell they’re achieving then the answer isn’t necessarily to go and find another agency.
You may need more clearly defined objectives, better performance measurement and/or experienced strategic oversight.
At Makin Marketing, I help business owners and leadership teams understand what’s working, challenge what isn’t and make more informed decisions about their marketing investment.
Whether you need an independent review of your current agency arrangements, help improving your marketing strategy or ongoing fractional leadership, I can provide a practical outside perspective.
Before spending more on marketing, make sure you’re getting the best possible value from what you’re already investing.
Get in touch with Makin Marketing or start with my free marketing assessment.
Because marketing accountability shouldn’t be an uncomfortable conversation. It should be a normal part of running a successful business.






